Coconut-Lime Sugar Cookies (If spring won't come to me...)

I'm seriously hitting a point where spring just needs to show up. I know that we have snow in April pretty much every year in Minneapolis, but it's usually interspersed with 50-degree days (and mud). This year, the ongoing "colder-than-average" temps, combined with snow that doesn't seem to end, is getting to all of us.

A couple of weeks ago, I bought some limes for a project that I ended up changing. And so with limes in the fridge I figured I was left with two options: Margaritas or baking. We have no tequila in the house, so I went for baking.

Here's the thing, though: I'm not really a "make it up as I go" baker. If you've been following me for any length of time, you know that I tend to fall back on tried-and-true recipes (or random new things that I've found a recipe for), instead of making things up on my own.

I do have one sugar cookie recipe, though, that I have already altered in the past (with lemon - and later with lemon and lavender), so I know that it plays well with add-ins. And, thus, with a friend's suggestion in the back of my mind, that lime and toasted coconut would work well together, I decided to try it out.

I'm pretty sure I've used this sugar cookie recipe before on the blog, though I can't find it. So here is the recipe as I have it from my mom:

In the "family cookbook" that we have, this is more specifically listed as "Donna Rettedal's Sugar Cookies" - because Donna is the one in my home town who made these and gave them to us (and gave the recipe to my mom).

Although I was making it up as I went along, I did want to measure things, in case I wanted to do it again. So I started with half a cup of coconut.

I wanted the coconut to be able to cool before adding it in, so I started that early (as you probably saw in the first video). I simply poured it into a dry pan on med-high heat, and stirred it around a bit as I waited until it was toasted.

How do you know when it's toasted? Well, I went for "when you can smell it, it's pretty much done."

I turned off the heat just when I started to smell it, and it looked great. Unfortunately, I didn't remove it from the pan, so it did get a brown, toasted color to it. Don't worry - it still tastes great, either way. And the fact that it was sweetened didn't seem to matter, which was a nice surprise.

In working with these with lemon, I've learned that about 2 teaspoons of zest work for a full batch.

You've used a zester before, right? You take off the colored part of the rind, and try to avoid getting any of the pith (the white stuff). Just make sure you don't also take off the outer level of your knuckle skin. (After all, we want green - not red...)

I recommend putting this in with the sugar, so that the oils can flavor the sugar before it gets "blocked" by the fats. Note: I recommend doing that - even though I may have gotten ahead of myself (as you can see in the photo above).

Oh. Speaking of the fats. I have a note from long long ago that says "works best with half shortening." Shortening, in this case, refers to something like Crisco, and I have to agree that these turn out best if it's half margarine (or butter) and half Crisco. Not sure what the chemistry is behind it, but it is what it is.

Fiona has apparently decided that she likes to supervise in the kitchen, and she did so during these cookies, as well.

When working with the lemon version, I tried out the amount of juice to use and found that swapping out 1 tablespoon of lemon juice for the 1 teaspoon of vanilla seemed to work well, so that's how I went with the lime juice.

Of course, this throws off the liquid/dry balance, so I also learned to add an extra half-cup of flour when making the modified recipe. With this new version, however, I was going to be adding my toasted coconut, so I kept the lower amount of flour.

Can you see the brown and green flecks in there? That's coconut and lime goodness.

I'm happy to say that the consistency of the dough was pretty much as expected, so I went ahead and dropped them onto an ungreased cookie sheet.

The next steps are kind of odd, but seem fairly important. For some reason, these don't like to flatten on their own (though they will spread just a bit), so you need to help that along.

You start with a plate of sugar, then "dip" the bottom of a glass into the bowl of dough to get it "primed" to pick up the sugar.

Dip into the sugar.

Mash the cookies to about 1/4-inch thick.

Repeat.

It's a great way to get out some of your aggressions - but don't go too far or you'll end up with wafers...

If you're someone who is never quite sure when cookies are done, these are a great cookie to work with. The "touch test" will go from the cookies being "airy, but mushy" on top when they're still under way, to feeling just a bit firm when they're done.

They also get a really nice golden edge around the bottom, which lends a nice texture once they cool.

I know from working with the lemon ones that these cookies never seem to have quite as much flavor as I want. (The original version simply has a calm vanilla undertone - but I always feel like there should be more kick with citrus.) So I decided to frost these.

My basic frosting recipe is:

• Dump some powdered sugar into a bowl - start with about 2 cups
• Add about a half teaspoon of softened margarine (for stability)
• Slowly add in enough liquid to get the consistency you want (depending on whether you're aiming for a frosting, a glaze, a spoonable treat, etc.). This liquid could be milk (if you're going for just a plain frosting) - with or without flavorings like almond, vanilla, or peppermint extract; it could be lemon juice or lime juice; it could even be water, if you're in a pinch.

Honestly. That's my recipe. You add more liquid if you want it thinner. You add more powdered sugar if you want it thicker. You add more margarine if you want it to be a little more stable right out of the gate. 

I know there are tons of recipes in the world for different frostings - from ganache to royal icing and everything in between - but I tend to go by feel on this.

Not a bowl of cucumber-dill sauce. I promise.

Each cooled cookie got a quick smear of frosting, and then they needed to sit on the rack until the frosting fully set up ("hardened" seems like to "hard" a word for this).

How did they taste? Well, Fiona was too tired/bored to give any opinion, ...

so I had to do it myself:

Here's hoping that you're getting spring wherever you are - or at least you've got a plan for bringing it on your own!

-----

Any ideas for what I can do to get spring to come even faster? Do you have a go-to spring recipe? A favorite Cinco de Mayo recipe you're hoping to find? Let me know and I'll see what I can do to add it to a future post!